Olsen & Sons
← Insights

Law firms · 6 min read

Generative AI in litigation: what the ethics rules actually ask of your firm

ABA Formal Opinion 512 in plain language, and the training it implies.

By David Olsen · November 21, 2026

In June 2023 a federal judge in New York sanctioned two lawyers and their firm $5,000 after a brief they filed cited cases that did not exist. The citations had come from ChatGPT (Mata v. Avianca, Inc., S.D.N.Y.). Since then similar stories have kept coming, and many courts have issued standing orders about AI use in filings.

The lesson most firms took was "be careful." That isn't a policy. The American Bar Association's Formal Opinion 512, issued in July 2024, is much more specific about what lawyers owe their clients when they use generative AI. Here it is in plain language. (Check your own state's rules and guidance too; several states have issued their own.)

Competence

Lawyers need a reasonable understanding of what the tools they use can and can't do, and they have to check the output. That is a training obligation, not just a warning to be careful.

Confidentiality

Before putting client information into a tool that may learn from it or share it, the lawyer has to understand the risk, and for many tools the opinion says informed client consent is needed. Your staff needs to know which tools are which.

Communication

In some situations clients should be told AI is being used, for example when it affects the representation or the fee, or when they ask.

Candor and meritorious claims

Everything filed with a court is still the lawyer's responsibility. Every citation and every quotation has to be verified by a person.

Supervision

Managing and supervising lawyers need firm-wide policies and training, for lawyers and for non-lawyer staff.

Fees

Firms can't bill clients for the time it takes a lawyer to learn a general-purpose tool, and hourly bills should reflect the time actually spent, even when AI made the work faster.

What this means in practice

Every one of those duties points to the same three things: a written firm policy, training for everyone who touches client work, and a habit of verification. None of that requires a big software purchase. It requires someone who knows both litigation and the tools to sit down with your team and do it.

I have spent more than twelve years running technology for a litigation firm and thousands of hours with these tools since they appeared. That is the training we give.

See what we'd change first.

Book a free Walkthrough. We spend about an hour seeing how your team works, and within two business days you get a one-page memo with the three changes we'd make first. It's yours whether or not you hire us.